LibraryArts & CraftsMusical InstrumentsPart 8: Ideas: Instruments, Mind, Philosophy and Society

INS-29

Instruments in mind and society

Learning an instrument and the brain, Philosophy of the instrument

1 min read · page 2 of 2

  1. Page 1: Sacred instruments and 2 more
  2. Page 2: Learning an instrument and the brain and 1 more

Overview

Page 2 of 2. On this page: Learning an instrument and the brain, Philosophy of the instrument. Back to the start of this section.

  • What studies show: musicians' brains differ in areas for hearing, movement and the link between the hemispheres (for example, Schlaug and colleagues, 1995); training improves listening and fine motor skill.
  • What is debated: big "far transfer" claims (that music lessons raise IQ or school marks) are weak in careful meta-analyses (Sala and Gobet, 2017 and 2020).
  • What is surely true: playing brings joy, discipline, community and a lifelong skill.

  • The instrument as body: players speak of an instrument becoming part of the body; the Indian ideal of the instrument "singing" (gayaki ang).
  • Authenticity: period instruments versus modern; the electric versus acoustic debate (Bob Dylan "goes electric", Newport, 1965).
  • Machines and humans: is a drum machine or an AI model an instrument, or a performer? Who is the artist?

Summary

  • Learning an instrument and the brain: musicians' brains differ in areas for hearing, movement and the link between the hemispheres (for example, Schlaug and colleagues, 1995)
  • Philosophy of the instrument: players speak of an instrument becoming part of the body
  • What studies show: musicians' brains differ in areas for hearing, movement and the link between the hemispheres (for example,…
  • What is debated: big "far transfer" claims (that music lessons raise IQ or school marks) are weak in careful meta-analyses…
  • What is surely true: playing brings joy, discipline, community and a lifelong skill.
  • The instrument as body: players speak of an instrument becoming part of the body
  • and 1 more on this page.
This section0 of 21 ticked
Tick a box when you have learned or tried something. Saved only on this device.

Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.

Musical Instruments