LibraryArts & CraftsMusical InstrumentsPart 0: Start here: five short questions
INS-00.03Why do a flute and a violin sound different on the same note?
Short answer: Because each instrument mixes its overtones in a different recipe and starts and ends its sound differently. This "colour" of a sound is called timbre (say TAM-ber).
The recipe of overtones
Every real note is a chord in disguise: the fundamental plus many quieter overtones. A flute's sound has strong fundamental and few overtones, so it sounds pure and breathy. A violin's sound has a rich spread of overtones, so it sounds bright and full. A clarinet, because its tube behaves as if closed at one end, is strong in the odd-numbered harmonics, which gives its hollow, woody sound.
Attack, sustain, decay
Timbre is also about time. A piano note hits hard and fades away; a violin can grow louder in the middle of a note; a tabla stroke cracks and rings. Scientists call this the envelope. Cut the attack off a recorded piano note and many people cannot tell it is a piano.
Materials and players
Wood, metal, skin, gut, nylon and steel each colour the overtones. So does the player. Ustad Bismillah Khan and another shehnai player sound different on the same instrument because of breath, lips and taste.
An Indian discovery
In 1920 C. V. Raman showed that the Indian mridangam and tabla are unusual drums. Most drums give overtones that clash (they are "inharmonic"), so they sound like thumps. The black spot of paste on these drums (the syahi or soru) loads the skin so that its overtones line up almost like a string's. That is why the tabla can be tuned to the tonic Sa and "sings".
Remember this: Same note, different recipe: timbre is the mix and the timing of overtones.
Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.
