LibraryArts & CraftsMusical InstrumentsPart 1: How Instruments Are Classified

INS-03

How the systems match (and a third from China)

2 min read

Overview

On this page: Where they disagree, Classing by role, not sound, Other systems, Our choice.

Indian (Natyashastra)Hornbostel–SachsChinese bayin (material)Indian examplesWorld examples
Tata (stretched)3 ChordophonesSilk (strings were silk)Veena, sitar, sarangi, santoorViolin, guitar, koto, guqin
Sushira (hollow)4 AerophonesBamboo, gourdBansuri, shehnai, shankhFlute, oboe, trumpet, sheng
Avanaddha (covered)2 MembranophonesSkin (leather)Tabla, mridangam, dholDjembe, timpani, taiko
Ghana (solid)1 IdiophonesMetal, stone, clay, woodManjira, ghatam, jal tarangGong, xylophone, mbira
(none)5 Electrophones (1940)(none)Electronic tanpura, OctapadSynthesizer, theremin
  • INS-03.1 Where they disagree: the harmonium is a sushira instrument in India but a "free aerophone" in H–S; the gopichand looks like a string instrument (tata) but H–S calls it a plucked drum because the skin, not the string, gives the tone. The piano is a struck zither (H–S), but many Indian writers treat it as a keyboard tata vadya.
  • INS-03.2 Classing by role, not sound: orchestras and bands sort by role: strings, woodwinds, brass, percussion, keyboards. This is why the flute (often metal) is a "woodwind" and the saxophone (brass) is also a woodwind (it uses a reed).
  • INS-03.3 Other systems: the Javanese gamelan groups instruments by musical function (melody, elaboration, punctuation); West African griot traditions group by caste and ceremony; the Indian Naubat or Naqqar khana courts grouped drums and shehnai as royal ensembles.
  • INS-03.4 Our choice: each instrument in this booklet carries both the Indian vadya and the H–S class, so Indian learners and world museums read the same map.

Summary

  • Where they disagree: the harmonium is a sushira instrument in India but a "free aerophone" in H–S
  • Classing by role, not sound: orchestras and bands sort by role: strings, woodwinds, brass, percussion, keyboards.
  • Other systems: the Javanese gamelan groups instruments by musical function (melody, elaboration, punctuation)
  • Our choice: each instrument in this booklet carries both the Indian vadya and the H–S class, so Indian learners and world…
This section0 of 4 ticked
Tick a box when you have learned or tried something. Saved only on this device.

Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.

Musical Instruments