LibraryArts & CraftsMusical InstrumentsPart 1: How Instruments Are Classified
INS-03How the systems match (and a third from China)
Overview
On this page: Where they disagree, Classing by role, not sound, Other systems, Our choice.
| Indian (Natyashastra) | Hornbostel–Sachs | Chinese bayin (material) | Indian examples | World examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tata (stretched) | 3 Chordophones | Silk (strings were silk) | Veena, sitar, sarangi, santoor | Violin, guitar, koto, guqin |
| Sushira (hollow) | 4 Aerophones | Bamboo, gourd | Bansuri, shehnai, shankh | Flute, oboe, trumpet, sheng |
| Avanaddha (covered) | 2 Membranophones | Skin (leather) | Tabla, mridangam, dhol | Djembe, timpani, taiko |
| Ghana (solid) | 1 Idiophones | Metal, stone, clay, wood | Manjira, ghatam, jal tarang | Gong, xylophone, mbira |
| (none) | 5 Electrophones (1940) | (none) | Electronic tanpura, Octapad | Synthesizer, theremin |
- INS-03.1 Where they disagree: the harmonium is a sushira instrument in India but a "free aerophone" in H–S; the gopichand looks like a string instrument (tata) but H–S calls it a plucked drum because the skin, not the string, gives the tone. The piano is a struck zither (H–S), but many Indian writers treat it as a keyboard tata vadya.
- INS-03.2 Classing by role, not sound: orchestras and bands sort by role: strings, woodwinds, brass, percussion, keyboards. This is why the flute (often metal) is a "woodwind" and the saxophone (brass) is also a woodwind (it uses a reed).
- INS-03.3 Other systems: the Javanese gamelan groups instruments by musical function (melody, elaboration, punctuation); West African griot traditions group by caste and ceremony; the Indian Naubat or Naqqar khana courts grouped drums and shehnai as royal ensembles.
- INS-03.4 Our choice: each instrument in this booklet carries both the Indian vadya and the H–S class, so Indian learners and world museums read the same map.
Summary
- Where they disagree: the harmonium is a sushira instrument in India but a "free aerophone" in H–S
- Classing by role, not sound: orchestras and bands sort by role: strings, woodwinds, brass, percussion, keyboards.
- Other systems: the Javanese gamelan groups instruments by musical function (melody, elaboration, punctuation)
- Our choice: each instrument in this booklet carries both the Indian vadya and the H–S class, so Indian learners and world…
This section0 of 4 ticked
Tick a box when you have learned or tried something. Saved only on this device.
Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.
