LibraryMedia & JournalismMoviesPart 0: Start here: five short questions
MOV-00.05Why were silent films never silent?
Short answer: Because almost every screening had live sound: a pianist, an organ, a full orchestra or, in Japan, a narrator called a benshi. The films had no recorded dialogue, but the cinema hall was full of music.
The music in the room
In big city cinemas of the 1910s and 1920s, orchestras played scores written or arranged for the film. Smaller halls had a single pianist who improvised to the mood: chase music, love music, danger music. Cinema organs were built with drums, bells and bird whistles. In India too, silent shows were accompanied by live musicians, and sometimes by a narrator explaining the story.
The storytellers of Japan
Japan's benshi stood beside the screen and voiced characters, explained scenes and added commentary. Popular benshi were stars, and audiences chose cinemas by who was narrating. Their popularity is one reason Japan kept making silent films well into the 1930s.
Telling a story with the face
Without speech, actors and directors invented a universal language: faces, bodies and editing. Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton and Harold Lloyd made comedy that needs no translation even today. Short written cards called intertitles gave dialogue or explanations, and could be swapped for any language, which made silent films easy to sell around the world.
An art that peaked and vanished
By the late 1920s, films such as F. W. Murnau's Sunrise (1927) and Carl Theodor Dreyer's The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928) showed how far the silent art had grown. Then, within about three years, it was nearly gone. Sadly, most silent films are lost: the Library of Congress estimates that around 75 percent of American silent features no longer survive, and only a few fragments of India's roughly 1,300 silent films remain.
Remember this: Silent cinema was a complete art of music, gesture and image, and it taught the world a shared language of the screen.
Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.
