LibraryMedia & JournalismMoviesPart 0: Start here: five short questions

MOV-00.07

Why do we cry for people who do not exist?

2 min read

Short answer: Because the brain responds to stories much as it responds to real people, and because a film gives us emotion in a safe frame. Indian aesthetics calls this tasting of emotion "rasa"; Aristotle called its cleansing effect "catharsis".

Keywords: why do we cry at movies, rasa theory explained, catharsis, psychology of film, paradox of fiction

The puzzle

You know the hero is an actor. You know the music was added later. You cry anyway. Philosophers call this the paradox of fiction (the philosopher Colin Radford asked it sharply in 1975): how can we feel real emotions for what we know is unreal?

What the brain does

When we watch a character, we read faces, follow goals and predict danger, using the same social skills we use with real people. Brain-imaging studies show that watching emotions activates regions also involved in feeling them. Research by Paul Zak's team has linked emotionally gripping stories to a rise in oxytocin, a hormone tied to empathy, though such results are still debated. The short version: the brain does not fully switch off its caring system just because the person is fictional.

Rasa: India's answer, 2,000 years old

The Natyashastra says a performance creates rasa, a "taste" of emotion that the audience savours. We do not suffer the hero's grief; we taste karuna (compassion) in a refined, shared form. Classical writers listed eight rasas, and later thinkers such as Abhinavagupta added shanta (peace), making the famous navarasa. A good Indian "masala" film often tries to serve many rasas in one sitting, like a thali.

Catharsis and safety

Aristotle wrote that tragedy arouses pity and fear and brings their catharsis, a release or cleansing. Psychologists today add that films give us a safe rehearsal: we feel loss, fear or love without the real cost, and practise feeling for others.

The editing trick

In the 1920s, Soviet filmmaker Lev Kuleshov reportedly showed the same neutral face after shots of soup, a coffin and a child, and viewers "saw" hunger, grief and joy. This Kuleshov effect shows that much of the emotion is built by us.

Remember this: Movies borrow the brain's machinery for caring about people, and give it a safe space to feel.

Next: Emotion on that scale became a business. How did movies become the world's biggest dream factory?

Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.

Movies