LibraryMedia & JournalismMoviesPart 9: Reviews and Voices

MOV-20

Critics' Corner: the great film critics

2 min read

Overview

On this page: Critics of the world, Critics and film writers of India, Review aggregators and audience ratings.

About Part 9: Reviews and Voices

  • André Bazin (France, 1918–1958): co-founded Cahiers du cinéma (1951); champion of realism and the long take; "father" of the New Wave.
  • François Truffaut (France): critic before director; his 1954 essay attacked "the tradition of quality" and launched auteurism.
  • James Agee (USA): poetic reviews in Time and The Nation in the 1940s.
  • Pauline Kael (USA, The New Yorker 1968–1991): passionate, personal, against snobbery; championed Bonnie and Clyde.
  • Andrew Sarris (USA, The Village Voice): brought auteur theory to America (The American Cinema, 1968).
  • Roger Ebert (USA, Chicago Sun-Times, 1967–2013): the first film critic to win a Pulitzer Prize (1975); "thumbs up" TV show with Gene Siskel; his "Great Movies" essays; he wrote that movies are "a machine that generates empathy".
  • Jonathan Rosenbaum, J. Hoberman, Manohla Dargis, A. O. Scott, Richard Brody, Kenneth Turan (USA).
  • Mark Kermode and Peter Bradshaw (UK); Sight and Sound magazine (BFI, 1932).
  • Tadao Sato (Japan) and Donald Richie (Japan's American interpreter).
  • Serge Daney (France), Jean-Michel Frodon, Michel Ciment (Positif).

  • Chidananda Dasgupta: co-founded the Calcutta Film Society with Satyajit Ray (1947); thoughtful critic and filmmaker.
  • Satyajit Ray as a writer: Our Films, Their Films (1976).
  • Iqbal Masud, Amita Malik, Bikram Singh, Khalid Mohamed (Times of India), Bhawana Somaaya, Maithili Rao.
  • Contemporary: Anupama Chopra (Film Companion), Rajeev Masand, Baradwaj Rangan (Tamil and pan-Indian), Shubhra Gupta (Indian Express), Saibal Chatterjee, Raja Sen, Sudhir Srinivasan, Namrata Joshi, Mayank Shekhar, Sukanya Verma.
  • Historians and scholars: Erik Barnouw and S. Krishnaswamy (Indian Film), Ashish Rajadhyaksha and Paul Willemen (Encyclopaedia of Indian Cinema), Firoze Rangoonwalla, Madhava Prasad, Ravi Vasudevan, S. Theodore Baskaran (Tamil cinema), P. K. Nair (archivist).

Rotten Tomatoes (1998; "Tomatometer" percentage of positive reviews), Metacritic (weighted average score), IMDb (1990; user ratings), Letterboxd (2011; social diary), BookMyShow ratings (India). One line on what each number really measures, and why a percentage is not a quality score.

Summary

  • Critics of the world: (France, 1918–1958): co-founded Cahiers du cinéma (1951)
  • Critics and film writers of India: co-founded the Calcutta Film Society with Satyajit Ray (1947)
  • Review aggregators and audience ratings: Rotten Tomatoes (1998
This section0 of 18 ticked
Tick a box when you have learned or tried something. Saved only on this device.

Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.

Movies