Polity Β· Part 4 β€” Amendment and Basic Structure Β· Major topic 14 of 44

Basic Structure Doctrine

The judicial doctrine that protects the Constitution's core from amendment.

33 items insideAsked 2Γ— in the RPSC/RSSB papers we analysed, most recently 2013POL-14

Also look at: Geography: Human Geography β€” 35. Indian Case Studies: Command-Area and Tribal Development

  1. 1

    Shankari Prasad case

    1951

    Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights

  2. 2

    Sajjan Singh case

    1965

    Reaffirmed Shankari Prasad

  3. 3

    Golaknath case

    1967

    Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights (prospective overruling)

  4. 4

    24th Amendment

    1971

    Parliament can amend any part including Fundamental Rights

    Asked 1Γ— Β· last 2013

  5. 5

    Kesavananda Bharati case

    1973

    Basic structure doctrine (13-judge bench, 7:6)

  6. 6

    Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj Narain

    1975

    Free and fair elections as basic structure

  7. 7

    42nd Amendment

    1976

    Article 368(4) and (5): no limitation on amending power

  8. 8

    Minerva Mills case

    1980

    Limited amending power is itself a basic feature; harmony between FR and DPSP

    Asked 1Γ— Β· last 2011

  9. 9

    Waman Rao case

    1981

    Basic structure applies to amendments after 24 April 1973

  10. 10

    S. R. Bommai case

    1994

    Secularism and federalism as basic structure

  11. 11

    I. R. Coelho case

    2007

    Ninth Schedule laws after 1973 open to judicial review

  12. 12

    NJAC judgment

    2015

    Judicial independence as basic structure; 99th Amendment struck down

  13. 13

    Elements of basic structure

    • Supremacy of the Constitution
    • Sovereign
    • Democratic
    • Republican nature
    • Secularism
    • Federalism
    • Separation of powers
    • Judicial review
    • Rule of law
    • Free and fair elections
    • Independence of judiciary
    • Parliamentary system
    • Limited amending power
    • Harmony between FR and DPSP
    • Welfare state
    • Essence of Fundamental Rights
  14. 14

    Significance and critique

    • Judicial overreach debate
    • Counter-majoritarian concerns
    • Global influence (Bangladesh, Kenya)