Polity Β· Part 4 β Amendment and Basic Structure Β· Major topic 14 of 44
Basic Structure Doctrine
The judicial doctrine that protects the Constitution's core from amendment.
33 items insideAsked 2Γ in the RPSC/RSSB papers we analysed, most recently 2013POL-14
Also look at: Geography: Human Geography β 35. Indian Case Studies: Command-Area and Tribal Development
- 1
Shankari Prasad case
1951Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights
- 2
Sajjan Singh case
1965Reaffirmed Shankari Prasad
- 3
Golaknath case
1967Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights (prospective overruling)
- 4
24th Amendment
1971Parliament can amend any part including Fundamental Rights
- 5
Kesavananda Bharati case
1973Basic structure doctrine (13-judge bench, 7:6)
- 6
Indira Nehru Gandhi v Raj Narain
1975Free and fair elections as basic structure
- 7
42nd Amendment
1976Article 368(4) and (5): no limitation on amending power
- 8
Minerva Mills case
1980Limited amending power is itself a basic feature; harmony between FR and DPSP
- 9
Waman Rao case
1981Basic structure applies to amendments after 24 April 1973
- 10
S. R. Bommai case
1994Secularism and federalism as basic structure
- 11
I. R. Coelho case
2007Ninth Schedule laws after 1973 open to judicial review
- 12
NJAC judgment
2015Judicial independence as basic structure; 99th Amendment struck down
- 13
Elements of basic structure
- Supremacy of the Constitution
- Sovereign
- Democratic
- Republican nature
- Secularism
- Federalism
- Separation of powers
- Judicial review
- Rule of law
- Free and fair elections
- Independence of judiciary
- Parliamentary system
- Limited amending power
- Harmony between FR and DPSP
- Welfare state
- Essence of Fundamental Rights
- 14
Significance and critique
- Judicial overreach debate
- Counter-majoritarian concerns
- Global influence (Bangladesh, Kenya)
