Polity · Part 5 — Systems of Government · Major topic 16 of 44

Parliamentary System of Government

Why India chose the Westminster model, and how it works in practice.

33 items insidePOL-16

Also look at: Geography: Indian Geography — 16. IrrigationEconomy: Public Procurement, Government Markets and State Capacity

  1. 1

    Features

    • Nominal and real executive
    • Majority party rule
    • Collective responsibility (Article 75)
    • Political homogeneity
    • Double membership
    • Leadership of PM
    • Dissolution of lower House
    • Secrecy
  2. 2

    Merits

    • Harmony between legislature and executive
    • Responsible government
    • Prevents despotism
    • Wide representation
    • Ready alternative government
  3. 3

    Demerits

    • Unstable government
    • No continuity of policies
    • Dictatorship of cabinet
    • Against separation of powers
    • Government by amateurs
  4. 4

    Reasons for adopting it

    • Familiarity
    • Preference for responsibility over stability
    • Need to avoid legislative–executive conflict
    • Nature of Indian society
  5. 5

    Indian vs British model

    • Republic vs monarchy
    • Parliamentary sovereignty vs constitutional supremacy
    • Judicial review
    • PM from either House
    • Legal responsibility of ministers
    • Shadow cabinet absent