LibraryArts & CraftsMusicPart 0: Start here: five short questions

MUS-00.02

Is music older than language?

1 min read

Short answer: Nobody knows for sure. Charles Darwin suggested that a "musical protolanguage" came before speech, and some researchers agree. Others think music grew out of language. Both use pitch, rhythm and emotion, and they share brain networks.

Keywords: music and language evolution, musical protolanguage, Darwin music, why humans make music

Darwin's guess

In The Descent of Man (1871), Darwin proposed that our ancestors sang before they spoke, using song in courtship. The archaeologist Steven Mithen (The Singing Neanderthals, 2005) argued for a shared "Hmmmmm" stage, holistic, musical and emotional.

The other view

The psychologist Steven Pinker once called music "auditory cheesecake": a pleasant by-product of abilities evolved for other purposes. Many researchers disagree, pointing to music's role in bonding (singing together releases endorphins and synchronises groups).

What babies tell us

Parents all over the world speak to babies in a sing-song voice ("motherese"), and lullabies across cultures sound alike. A 2018 Harvard study (Mehr and colleagues) found that people could guess whether a song from an unfamiliar culture was a lullaby, a dance song or a healing song.

India's view

Indian tradition treats sound itself as sacred: nada brahma, "sound is the absolute". The Samaveda set Rigvedic verses to melody.

Remember this: Music and language are cousins; which came first is still an open question.

Next: India built the most detailed system linking music to time. Why does a raga change with the time of day?

Tip: the ← and → keys also turn the pages.

Music